In Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, did the mistress's initial kindness or her eventual cruelty have a greater effect on Frederick...

The eventual cruelty of Douglass's mistress, Mrs. Auld, had a greater effect on him than her initial kindness. At first, Mrs. Auld, who had never had a slave before, was "a woman of the kindest heart and finest feelings" (page 19). She did not realize that it was considered dangerous to teach a slave to read, thereby encouraging the slave's independence of thought, so she started to teach Frederick Douglass to read when he was...

The eventual cruelty of Douglass's mistress, Mrs. Auld, had a greater effect on him than her initial kindness. At first, Mrs. Auld, who had never had a slave before, was "a woman of the kindest heart and finest feelings" (page 19). She did not realize that it was considered dangerous to teach a slave to read, thereby encouraging the slave's independence of thought, so she started to teach Frederick Douglass to read when he was young. Upon discovering what his wife was doing, Mr. Auld told her "that is unlawful, as well as unsafe, to teach a slave to read" (page 20). Mr. Auld feared that teaching a slave to read might make the slave rebellious and more prone to escape. Frederick Douglass said at this moment that he understood how the white man kept the black person enslaved, and "I understood the pathway from slavery to freedom." (page 20). He realized that if reading was so dangerous for slaves, the key to freedom was learning how to read. Frederick Douglass's acquisition of the ability to read allowed him to have the psychological power and tactical means to escape northward. Therefore, his mistress' cruelty had a greater effect on him than her kindness.